Why I’m Not A Minimalist

So! Unless you’ve been living under a rock lately, you’ve probably noticed that minimalism is totally the Next Big Thing. Or, possibly, the Big Thing Now. But me, I’m not a fan of minimalism, and here’s why:

First of all, the aesthetic does absolutely nothing for me. I’ve never favored lots of white (hurts my head)  and I’ve always preferred lots of colors. Just black and white, with all those hard edges? Yuck!

Secondly, I’ve noticed a lot of times when minimalism comes up, it’s talked about with an air of moral superiority, and I don’t know if I agree with that. I definitely think mindless overconsumption is bad; buying the most/cheapest/best (or any combination thereof) of everything all the time doesn’t do anyone any good. And I think this is definitely the default in most of today’s consumption. But at the same time, I think such a thing as mindful consumption is very possible. And I don’t think it’s inherently bad just because it’s consumption, even if you’re buying purely ornamental items. Like, say, in a house, because for a lot of people, the state of their house is intrinsically linked to the state of their head.

How can we consume thoughtfully? Ask yourself lots of questions before buying something – where was this made? how will I dispose of it when the time comes? how long will I keep/use it? why do I want it? am I trying to fill an emotional hole with it? For  fashion items: I try not to buy clothing/shoes/accessories unless I can think of 2-3 outfits while I’m in the store to wear it with. If I can’t do that, I put it back on the rack & think for 24 hours. Most of the time, when the 24 hours is up, I’ve totally forgotten about the item. Obviously that’s not really something I need or even want that bad!

I don’t think buying things for the sake of buying them is a good idea by any means, but I don’t think buying things is evil in and of itself. What do you think?

  • http://lesadventuresdulorax.blogspot.com lorax

    I like your idea that what’s in your home reflects the state of your head. I’ve always felt that about the state of my home, but I’ve never applied the idea to minimalism. You’ve got a good point there. I’ve never been a fan of minimalism. But, since it’s been around since the 80s, maybe it will go away soon? Or perhaps us anti-minimalists are cursed and it will never go away.

    Also, I like your 24-hour rule. I’m going to implement that on my next shopping trip.

  • http://www.glassofwin.com Rachael

    I think it’s kind of ironic when, especially in regards to minimalist homes, that people go to great lengths (and big financies) to look like they have so little. Personally, I liked a well-loved, lived-in look.
    .-= Rachael´s last blog ..Product Review: Purity Facial Cleanser + MD Skincare Vitamin C Serum =-.

  • http://www.wicked-whimsy.com Michelle

    @Rachel – yes! I was thinking minimalists like…Zen Habits…but I have definitely seen what you speak of here too.

    @Lorax – the 24 hour rule has saved me from MANY a silly purchase. I highly recommend it!

  • http://www.innyvinny.com Alicia

    I also don’t agree with the perceived or assumed superiority that comes with minimalism. However, the idea of wanting less has always appealed to me. I’m probably never going to be able to do the all white walls with 50 items to my name, so I guess I’m going for mindful consumption as you’ve laid it out here…with the shoe shopping being a bit more wreckless. LOL.

  • http://stylishthought.com Fajr

    I’m certainly not a minimalist as I like things Big, bold and outrageous! But I can appreciate consuming less and evaluating everything I buy to make sure it’s truly needed and has a place. I feel like fashion’s love of minimalism comes with the superiority complex and not really about parring down.

  • http://www.wicked-whimsy.com Michelle

    Fajr – yes! That’s exactly how I feel about it too!

    Alicia – yeah, I don’t think there’s anything wrong with wanting less – I think it’s a noble goal to aim for, but I don’t think it’s for everyone, though.